Skip to content
Toggle Navigation
Home
About
Ice Cream
Seasonal BBQ
Shop
Contact
Toggle Navigation
WooCommerce Cart
WooCommerce My Account
Username:
Password:
Remember Me
Register
Search for:
Shop
Blue Cheese
Goat Cheese
Imported Cheese
Italian Cheese
Jack Cheese
Muenster Cheese
Processed Cheese
Swiss Cheese
Other Cheese
Cheese Curd
Meats
Honey
Maple Syrup
Gift Cards
All Cheddar Cheese
Cheddar Aged Profiles
Spiced Cheddar
Spreads
Sort by
Name
Sort by
Default Order
Sort by
Name
Sort by
Price
Sort by
Date
Sort by
Popularity
Sort by
Rating
Show
32 Products
Show
32 Products
Show
64 Products
Show
96 Products
10X Sharp Cheddar – Aged 10 Years (1 pound)
$
25.83
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
12X Sharp Cheddar – Aged 12 Years (1 pound)
$
28.02
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
15X Sharp Cheddar – Aged 15 Years (1 pound)
$
33.27
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
4X Sharp Cheddar – Aged 48+ months (1 pound)
$
18.99
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
5X Sharp Cheddar – Aged 5 Years (1 pound)
$
19.93
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
7X Farmstead Cheddar – Aged 7 Years (1 pound)
$
22.03
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Aged Asiago Spread
$
6.40
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Asiago Cheese (1 pound)
$
14.05
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Baby Swiss Cheese (1 pound)
Rated
5.00
out of 5
$
14.05
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Bacon Horse Processed Cheese (1 pound)
$
14.85
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Bacon/Horseradish Spread
$
2.40
–
$
6.40
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Basic Cheese Curd (by the ounce)
Rated
5.00
out of 5
$
5.45
–
$
38.00
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Beer Kaese – German Limburger Cheese (1 pound)
$
16.15
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Blue Cheese Spread
$
6.40
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Blue Domestic Cheese (1 pound)
$
14.05
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Blue Imported Cheese – Denmark (1 pound)
$
18.25
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Brick Cheese (1 pound)
$
10.90
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Buffalo Wing Cheese Curd (by the ounce)
$
5.80
–
$
39.00
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Buffalo Wing Processed Cheese (1 pound)
$
14.85
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Caraway Processed Processed Cheese (1 pound)
$
14.85
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Cheddar Spread
$
2.40
–
$
6.40
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Chive Cheese Curd (by the ounce)
$
5.80
–
$
39.00
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Chocolate Nut Cheese Fudge (1 pound)
$
18.35
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Colby Jack Cheese (1 pound)
$
10.90
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Croghan Bologna (1 pound)
$
17.68
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Dill Cheese Curd (by the ounce)
$
5.80
–
$
39.00
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Extra Sharp Cheddar – Aged 12 Months (by the pound)
$
10.90
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Farmers Cheese (1 pound)
$
11.95
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Fisherman’s Delight Cheddar – Aged 14 Months (by the pound)
$
12.06
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Garlic & Chive Cheese Curd (by the ounce)
$
5.80
–
$
39.00
Select options
This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Details
Quick View
Garlic Processed Processed Cheese (1 pound)
$
14.85
Add to cart
Details
Quick View
Gift Certificate (online only)
$
25.00
–
$
175.00
Select amount
Details
Quick View
1
2
3
Next
Close product quick view
×
Title
Page load link
Go to Top